Запоздало возвращаюсь к дискуссии по поводу этических следствий иллюзионизма. Артём Беседин написал обширный ответ мне, в котором попытался отклонить некоторые из моих возражений и предложил собственный «аргумент куба агонии». В своей объёмной заметке подробно рассматриваю проблемные места аргументации Артёма и показываю, что аргумент куба агонии бьёт по иллюзионизму куда больнее, чем по квалиа-реализму.
Запоздало возвращаюсь к дискуссии по поводу этических следствий иллюзионизма. Артём Беседин написал обширный ответ мне, в котором попытался отклонить некоторые из моих возражений и предложил собственный «аргумент куба агонии». В своей объёмной заметке подробно рассматриваю проблемные места аргументации Артёма и показываю, что аргумент куба агонии бьёт по иллюзионизму куда больнее, чем по квалиа-реализму.
What distinguishes the app from competitors is its use of what's known as channels: Public or private feeds of photos and videos that can be set up by one person or an organization. The channels have become popular with on-the-ground journalists, aid workers and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, who broadcasts on a Telegram channel. The channels can be followed by an unlimited number of people. Unlike Facebook, Twitter and other popular social networks, there is no advertising on Telegram and the flow of information is not driven by an algorithm. Ukrainian forces successfully attacked Russian vehicles in the capital city of Kyiv thanks to a public tip made through the encrypted messaging app Telegram, Ukraine's top law-enforcement agency said on Tuesday. This ability to mix the public and the private, as well as the ability to use bots to engage with users has proved to be problematic. In early 2021, a database selling phone numbers pulled from Facebook was selling numbers for $20 per lookup. Similarly, security researchers found a network of deepfake bots on the platform that were generating images of people submitted by users to create non-consensual imagery, some of which involved children. One thing that Telegram now offers to all users is the ability to “disappear” messages or set remote deletion deadlines. That enables users to have much more control over how long people can access what you’re sending them. Given that Russian law enforcement officials are reportedly (via Insider) stopping people in the street and demanding to read their text messages, this could be vital to protect individuals from reprisals. In addition, Telegram's architecture limits the ability to slow the spread of false information: the lack of a central public feed, and the fact that comments are easily disabled in channels, reduce the space for public pushback.
from id
